Why Email Still Beats Every Platform You're Spending Money On

Here's a thought experiment. Imagine Meta decided tomorrow that business accounts can no longer post promotional content without paying for reach. Or that Instagram's algorithm shifted again, halving your organic engagement overnight.

Neither of these is hypothetical. Both have happened, repeatedly, to real businesses.

Now imagine the same scenario with your email list. Someone who has willingly given you their email address and confirmed they want to hear from you. Can Meta take that away? Can an algorithm bury it?

No. That relationship is yours.

This is why, despite being the oldest digital marketing channel still in active use, email consistently outperforms social media on the metrics that actually matter: conversions, revenue, and return on investment.

The Numbers That Keep Getting Ignored

The data on email ROI has been consistent for years. For every dollar spent on email marketing, businesses see returns in the range of $36 to $42, according to research from Litmus and the Data and Marketing Association. No other digital channel comes close. Organic search is the only rival, and SEO takes months to compound.

Compare that to paid social, where the average cost per click on Meta has risen steadily since 2021, and organic reach for business pages is now well under 5% of your followers on a typical post.

Email open rates vary by industry, but business-to-consumer averages sit around 20 to 30%. That means roughly one in four people on your list reads your email. On Instagram, that same organic reach for a business account is closer to 3 to 5% of followers. And those are followers who actively chose to follow you.

The math is not subtle.

Why SMEs Underinvest in Email

Most SME owners I speak to have a version of the same story: they set up an email account, sent a few newsletters, saw "okay" open rates, and then got distracted by whatever platform was hot that quarter.

Three things tend to get in the way.

The list never got big enough. You can't see the power of email with 87 subscribers. The compounding effect kicks in somewhere around 500 to 1,000 engaged contacts, and most businesses give up before they get there.

The content was a press release, not a conversation. "We're excited to announce our new service" is not an email people want to read. They signed up to get value: practical advice, exclusive offers, things they can use. When emails feel like corporate announcements, unsubscribes spike.

No clear system. Social media has obvious prompts (post something, post something else). Email requires more deliberate thinking: what's the sequence, how often, what do we want people to do. Without a system, it becomes the marketing task that's always getting pushed to next week.

None of these are hard to fix. But they require making email a priority, not an afterthought.

What You Actually Own vs. What You're Renting

This is the frame that shifts how most business owners think about their marketing mix.

When you build a following on Instagram, you're renting an audience from Meta. Same with TikTok followers, LinkedIn connections, and YouTube subscribers. The platform owns the relationship. They set the terms. They can change the algorithm, reduce your reach, or in Deliveroo's case, simply announce they're shutting down operations with a week's notice.

We wrote about this when Deliveroo announced its exit from Singapore. F&B owners who had invested entirely in GrabFood and Deliveroo for customer acquisition suddenly had no direct way to contact the people they'd served for years. No email list. No WhatsApp database. Nothing they owned.

Contrast that with email. Your list is yours. You export it, move platforms, migrate tools: the contacts come with you. No algorithm decides who sees your next email. No ad budget required to reach people who already said yes to hearing from you.

This isn't anti-social media. Social media has real value for discovery, awareness, and community building. The mistake is treating it as the destination rather than the funnel.

How to Build an Email List That Actually Grows

Building a list of 10,000 engaged subscribers doesn't happen by accident. Here's the practical sequence.

Start with a lead magnet worth trading an email for. A 10% discount is fine. A genuinely useful resource, such as a checklist, a guide, or a free assessment, is better. What does your ideal customer want badly enough to share their email address? Start there.

Put the sign-up form where people are already paying attention. On your website, this means above the fold on your homepage, inside high-traffic blog posts, and on your contact page. On social, it means a link in your bio and periodic posts that direct people to sign up.

Use WhatsApp strategically. For most SMEs, WhatsApp is the primary channel for transactional and service conversations. That's the right use for it. For marketing purposes: promotions, content, nurture sequences, email is more scalable. You can't easily segment a WhatsApp broadcast list or automate follow-up sequences at any real scale.

Set up a welcome sequence. The best time to send someone an email is the moment they subscribe, while you're top of mind. A three-email welcome sequence (one to introduce yourself, one to deliver value, one to make a relevant offer) can be set up once and run indefinitely. It's the closest thing to passive marketing that actually works.

The Local Angle Worth Knowing

There's an argument that email is even more valuable for SMEs here than it is globally, for one specific reason: the market is small.

You're not trying to build an email list of 100,000 people. A list of 2,000 to 5,000 engaged contacts in your niche, whether that's local homeowners, F&B operators, clinic administrators, or retail buyers, is genuinely powerful at this scale. Each subscriber represents a real person you can reach directly, without paying a platform for the privilege.

There are also specific compliance requirements to know about. Under the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) and the Spam Control Act, you need either explicit consent (someone actively signed up) or business consent (an existing customer relationship). Do not buy lists. Do not add people without permission. This isn't just legal good practice: lists built on consent perform dramatically better because the subscribers actually want to hear from you.

If you're using email for marketing, your messages should include an unsubscribe mechanism and your business contact information. Most email platforms handle this automatically. If you're building something custom, make sure it's included.

The Realistic Investment

Email marketing tools start at free. Mailchimp's free tier covers up to 500 subscribers and 1,000 emails per month: enough to get started and test your approach before spending anything. Most SMEs running serious campaigns spend $30 to $150 per month on email platforms, depending on list size and automation needs.

The bigger investment is time: writing emails that people actually want to read. The good news is that one well-written email can double as a LinkedIn post, a blog post draft, or an SMS follow-up. Email thinking forces clarity that makes everything else better.

The math works out clearly for most businesses. If your email list drives even one or two extra sales per month that you wouldn't have otherwise made, the platform cost pays for itself many times over.

Where to Start This Week

If you haven't sent a marketing email in the last three months, here's your practical starting point:

1. Pick an email platform. Mailchimp and MailerLite are both solid for SMEs.
2. Import any existing customer contacts who have given you permission to market to them.
3. Write one email. Not a newsletter. One email with one point and one clear call to action.
4. Send it.
5. Look at the open rate and click rate. Iterate from there.

You don't need a 12-month content calendar before you start. You need to send the first email, see who responds, and learn from it.

The business owners who build real marketing assets, such as a content library, an SEO presence, and an email list, tend to be the ones still growing five years later when the platforms have changed three times. The ones who chased every new channel without building anything they own tend to start from scratch every two years.

Email isn't exciting. That's precisely why it works.

---

Magnified helps SMEs build owned marketing channels that compound over time. If you're looking at your marketing mix and wondering what to prioritise, talk to us.